Grading policy for Req-1

-1 Vision or Purpose missing

-2 Validation of requirements missing/ incorrect

-2 Not enough of the requirements covered

-1 writing sins

-1 Did not say what requirements would be added later



RUP:

-3 if usecases or scenarios missing

-2 if fit critera is incorrect, and requirements numbered wrong

-2 if usecases not understood correctly

-1 if no mapping between requirements and use-cases/scenarios

-1 if outcome of usecases not labelled

-1 Volere requirements not broken down well



XP:

-3 if user stories or tasks missing

-2 if user stories not understood correctly

-1 No mapping of user stories with tasks

-1 Tasks not broken down well